HomeIndiaDemand for CEC Gyanesh Kumar’s Resignation Grows: Election Commission Says SIR Order...

Demand for CEC Gyanesh Kumar’s Resignation Grows: Election Commission Says SIR Order Was Unanimous

Published on

6 min read

New Delhi, September 26: The opposition’s campaign demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar intensified on Saturday. The Congress held protests at several places, including Delhi, Bengaluru and Dehradun, while the Election Commission, after a meeting at Nirvachan Sadan in New Delhi, issued a press note saying the SIR order had been issued with the unanimous approval of the whole Commission.

Update (October 12): The INDIA bloc’s “Chalo Dilli” march was stopped near the Supreme Court, and Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge filed a writ petition against the Election Commission. Full story: INDIA bloc’s march stopped near the Supreme Court. Our explainer on the whole campaign: How a newspaper investigation intensified calls for the CEC’s resignation

Update (October 3): Protests were held in Delhi and Mumbai on Gandhi Jayanti, and hundreds were detained in Delhi. Full story: Protests over the demand for the CEC’s resignation; CJP sets an October 10 deadline

Key highlights

  • The row began with a newspaper report of September 23, which said Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi recorded written objections to the CEC’s decisions at least 14 times in 10 months.
  • The Election Commission says differing views are a normal part of its decision-making and that all orders were issued under the law.
  • On September 26 the Commission reiterated that the SIR order of June 24, 2025, was issued with the unanimous approval of the Commission.
  • Opposition parties are preparing a fresh notice in both Houses of Parliament to remove the CEC; a notice signed by 73 MPs in April is already pending in the Rajya Sabha.
  • The BJP has called the allegations an attack on institutions.

The root of the row: dissent inside the Commission

According to the September 23 newspaper report, the two Election Commissioners objected 14 times over the past 10 months to decisions which, they said, were issued without their knowledge. The objections related to changes in Form 6 for voter registration, revision of electoral rolls and control over the centralised database. The report also said the two commissioners had written to the Cabinet Secretary about oversight of voter data systems.

In the three-member Election Commission, decisions are usually taken by consensus; where there is disagreement, the majority view prevails. So the report of repeated objections by two commissioners raised the question of how major decisions had been taken.

The Election Commission’s position

On the day the report appeared, the Commission issued a statement saying that written notes, comments and technical suggestions are a normal part of institutional deliberation, that all orders had legal approval and that due process was followed. The Commission also said about 40 initiatives and reforms over the past year had been approved unanimously by the full Commission.

On Saturday, September 26, after a meeting of the CEC and both commissioners at Nirvachan Sadan, a press note discussed extending the dates for new voter registration and the SIR, and made clear that the SIR order of 24.6.2025 for all states and union territories had been issued with the Commission’s unanimous approval.

Timeline of the row

DateEvent
June 24, 2025SIR (special intensive revision) order issued for all states and UTs
April 2026Removal-style notices against the CEC rejected; a notice signed by 73 MPs is said to be pending in the Rajya Sabha
September 23, 2026A newspaper reports 14 written objections by two Election Commissioners in 10 months; ECI responds the same day
September 25, 2026Youth Congress and Delhi Congress march stopped in Delhi
September 26, 2026Protests in Bengaluru and Dehradun; ECI says the SIR order was unanimous

The opposition on the streets

  • Delhi (September 25): the Youth Congress and Delhi Pradesh Congress tried to march to the Election Commission’s office but were stopped near the party offices. The NSUI also protested.
  • Bengaluru: Karnataka Congress leaders held a sit-in at Freedom Park and asked the President to remove the CEC. D.K. Shivakumar alleged that names of eligible voters had been deleted. The Congress made an issue of notices to, and deletions of, lakhs of voters during the SIR in Karnataka.
  • Dehradun (September 26): the Uttarakhand Congress marched to the Secretariat, burnt an effigy of the CEC and sent a memorandum to the President. Harish Rawat, Yashpal Arya, Ganesh Godiyal and Kumari Selja were present.

In the Lok Sabha, the Congress’s Gaurav Gogoi has demanded a special session of Parliament. The TMC’s Abhishek Banerjee and leaders of the DMK, RJD and SP have also demanded the CEC’s removal and a halt to the SIR.

Meanwhile, the new political group “Cockroach Janta Party” (CJP) had given the CEC a 48-hour ultimatum to resign and warned of a nationwide movement from Jantar Mantar if the demand was not met. The CJP said it would begin protests across the country from October 2.

The BJP’s response

BJP MP Sambit Patra said correspondence inside the Commission was official deliberation and a sign of a healthy democracy. The party alleges that the opposition is targeting constitutional institutions after losing elections.

How easy is it to remove the CEC?

The Chief Election Commissioner can be removed only in the same way as a Supreme Court judge: by a motion passed by a special majority in both Houses of Parliament, on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity. With the present numbers in Parliament, such a motion is hard to pass with the opposition’s votes alone. In April, the Rajya Sabha Chairman and the Lok Sabha Speaker rejected impeachment-style notices against the CEC, and one notice signed by 73 MPs is said to be still pending in the Rajya Sabha.

What to watch

  • A fresh notice to remove the CEC, which the opposition may submit in both Houses next week.
  • The CJP’s nationwide protests announced from October 2.
  • New state-wise dates for the SIR, which will become clear from the Commission’s notification.

What it means

The row comes while the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls is under way in several states. The most important thing for voters is to check their names in the draft roll and, if needed, file Form 6 (new name) or claims and objections on time. Read our report on the SIR process in Delhi: Delhi SIR 2026: how to check your name in the draft list.

This article was first published in Hindi and has been translated. The Press of Asia now publishes in English only.

Written by
National Desk

The National Desk covers India's politics, governance, security and public-interest news. Stories are checked against at least two credible sources before publication.

Latest News

Latest News

UN E-Government Survey 2026 Puts AI Agents, Human Oversight and Digital Divides in Focus

The UN’s 2026 e-government survey examines a shift towards agentic public services, while highlighting connectivity gaps, usability and human oversight.

Trump, Xi and Putin Issue Shenzhen Declaration on Nuclear Risks and Energy Supply

The three leaders’ Shenzhen declaration addresses nuclear risks, energy flows and UN reform. It does not announce a ceasefire or a nuclear reduction treaty.

Vietnam Takes Over APEC 2027 Host Role, With Phu Quoc Set for Leaders’ Week

Vietnam formally received the APEC 2027 host role from China in Shenzhen. Phu Quoc will host the culminating leaders’ week.

Hong Kong’s John Lee Courts Peru Trade and Singapore Technology Investment at APEC

John Lee met Peru’s Keiko Fujimori and Singapore’s Lawrence Wong at APEC, promoting an existing FTA and technology investment opportunities.

Related Coverage

EU and UK Prepare November 20 Brussels Summit With Trade, Security and Migration on Agenda

EU and UK leaders are preparing their second summit since Brexit. The Brussels meeting will review cooperation and security priorities; outcomes are still pending.

Australia Expands West Bank Sanctions, Targeting Three People and Four Organisations

Australia announces targeted sanctions over West Bank settlement expansion, including its first such action against a construction company. The measures are targeted, not a general trade ban.

Quad Leaders Plan 2027 Maritime-Aircraft Exercise and First Business Forum

The Quad’s Manila statement sets out a 2027 maritime-aircraft exercise, a business forum and cooperation on cables, cybersecurity and AI.